monroe's are good for a stock suspension.
KYBs are much better for a sportier, or lowered, suspension.
I don't know what your basis is for saying that Monroe sucks, but all I can tell you is that I read tons of customer reviews on many different web sites before making my decision and I don't recall reading any negative reviews on Monroe's. On the other hand, I read a number of negative reviews on KYB's and other brands, most of them saying that they made the ride too harsh. A number of guys removed their KYB's and replaced them with Monroe's and were well satisfied. I guess it's all a matter of personal preference and opinion. Maybe it will turn out that you're right about Monroe. Only time will tell. But for now, I couldn't be more pleased with mine and what they did for my car.
I don't know what your basis is for saying that Monroe sucks, but all I can tell you is that I read tons of customer reviews on many different web sites before making my decision and I don't recall reading any negative reviews on Monroe's. On the other hand, I read a number of negative reviews on KYB's and other brands, most of them saying that they made the ride too harsh. A number of guys removed their KYB's and replaced them with Monroe's and were well satisfied. I guess it's all a matter of personal preference and opinion. Maybe it will turn out that you're right about Monroe. Only time will tell. But for now, I couldn't be more pleased with mine and what they did for my car.
Wow I read the first couple of posts and was like 'these guys are crazy!' The whole spring compressor thing is unnessary unless you are trying to install a combination of performance parts or something. If you are just trying to get your struts back to the way they were originally, you can just get some loaded struts from completestruts.com. DON'T get any of the cheap ones off ebay because they are JUNK. I've had the unity struts on mine and they are very much like Monroe's with stiffer springs and they were a better price. I used to like Monroe but their new struts suck because they are made in some third world country. Monroe Quick Strut repeated problems????? - Car Forums and Automotive Chat
-rdp