Just by taking off the belt for the SC my DIC was giving me 2-3 mpg more. I haven't tested this by hand and paper but there was a few times that I almost got hit pulling out and being able to hammer it to make tight gaps in traffic. I'm averaging about 21-23 mpg in town with 107,500 miles on th engine. Only things I've done to it is replaced a few idler pulleys and new autolite plugs.
you get bad mileage then, I am getting 23 with mine running the s/c and have a cam (and 150k on the engine)
Maybe in your case you get bad mileage, I was refering to my stock GTP gets better mileage in the city without the supercharger belt but only 1-2 mpg's.
your getting the same as I am and mines not stock is my point. Disabling the sc will cause an air restriction so it shouldn't help (you have to get air past the rotors that are no longer spinning)