Window rattle worse

[WhiteDevil]

I posted last fall about a side window rattle when its 1/4 of the way down or less. I cant figure it out, I push the door panel with my knee it stops, I grab the window glass edge it stops... Is the framing loose in the door?

Anyone had the panels off and notice if it was bolted or riveted in? the window support arms and tracking.


Thanks in advance. Its getting really annoying and the dealership says it aint happening for them.