Ok. That makes sense and I'm sure I tilted it trying to get it out that first time.
Even this time when I pulled the lim off, the gaskets looked ok and in place. One thing I'm not sure about is the side gasket strips that came with the kit. It had two red colored strips which I fit on no problem. There were also two blue (iirc) pieces that I didn't know how to use.
Here's a picture after I tore it apart the second time.