I had what sounded like a broken flexplate (a rattling, metallic sound at idle that quieted down/went away with the application of throttle), but I have my transmission out of the car and the flexplate looks to still be intact. What else could cause something like this. I noticed that the input shaft of my trans has a lot more in/out play in it than the one I'm planning on putting in. Also, I was able to push the torque converter side to side (like checking for a bad wheel bearing) and it seemed to move a good, noticeable amount.
I'd like to get this thing put back in the car tonight, so any and all information/suggestions welcome.